Fixing the SG spam problem.

Pitch your ideas and advice to help make SG a better place.

Moderator: man of txt

Post Reply
User avatar
Slashley
Namcot Voucher|Namco Voucher|Namco Voucher
Namcot Voucher|Namco Voucher|Namco Voucher
Level 58 — 666 posts84 posts to next level
Posts: 666
Joined: Wed Oct 13, 2004 6:57 pm
Location: Helsinki, Finland

Fixing the SG spam problem.

Post by Slashley »

I'm sure everyone who is active on this board has noticed that we have a slight spammer problem.

The fixes are multiple. It's not my bloody job, but it looks like others aren't even interested in fixing it. So here, have just a few ideas on how to deal with it. -_-





1. Most bots, let's assume about 98% of them, go to the first View the comments that have been posted so far. (Post your comment) link on the main page of the forum.

An attempt should be made to fool the bots. Putting up a non-functional link as the first one may work. For example, adding the following line below "E3: Final Fantasy XIII trilogy unveiled!":
View the comments that have been posted so far. (Post your comment)

However, this method is not guaranteed to work. Bots may be configured to use the first working link.




2: If a defunct link tactic won't work, it's possible to fool scripts by other means. For example, make a "spam goes here" thread. Link that on the main page. Delete thread, remake once a week (or daily if you can be arsed). Out of sight, out of mind. Majority of the problem solved.






3. A harder but by far most efficient solution: customise the registeration.

Currently, according to man of txt in some other thread we currently use the "newest" anti-bot registeration stuff. Sadly, copy-pasta = bad. The reason why Windows has the most viruses? It's the most common OS. The reason why "our" registeration bot-check has been cracked? It's the most common version out there. Even the slightest variation of this, however, will probably cause the bots be unable to register.

For example, adding a new box with "Insert PIKACHU into the box below, thank you!" will probably break automated registeration. It won't bother any living being but a script cannot comprehend it. IF some botmaster visits and codes an improvement to his bot (which I VERY much doubt) it's easy to fix again by reversing the text box. For example "Do NOT insert PIKACHU into the box below, thank you!" will again not hinder humans at all, but will stop any bots programmed to find the word after 'insert'. Variations are infinite and each slight alteration will cause a few hours or up to even weeks of bot-free SG. Or possibly forever bot-free, even.






4. Make a script to automatically delete the first post of all users, once only. These fire-and-forget bot accounts are only used for one spam post.

A bad solution in all ways. Needs scripting, might not even be possible, and will hinder humans.







So yeah, use any of the above. OR USE YOUR HEAD AND COME UP WITH SOMETHING. You aren't even freaking dealing with a living mind, you're dealing with a bloody text file. Squaregamer.com is just one of hundreds of lines in there.
This thread is crap. :x
User avatar
Lord Golbez
Pokémony
Pokémony
Level 99 — 26073 postsMaximum level reached
Posts: 26073
Joined: Thu Sep 09, 2004 10:38 pm
Location: DC

Re: Fixing the SG spam problem.

Post by Lord Golbez »

Slashley wrote: 2: If a defunct link tactic won't work, it's possible to fool scripts by other means. For example, make a "spam goes here" thread. Link that on the main page. Delete thread, remake once a week (or daily if you can be arsed). Out of sight, out of mind. Majority of the problem solved.
What are you kidding me? Do you even know where you're posting? Regular posters will post in that thread just because it's there. :p

Besides, I've seen bots posting in more than one News thread during the same period, so it wouldn't get rid of all spam anyway.

Number 3 sounds like a pretty good option though.
The TBB offers you tea and biscuits. :tea
User avatar
Slashley
Namcot Voucher|Namco Voucher|Namco Voucher
Namcot Voucher|Namco Voucher|Namco Voucher
Level 58 — 666 posts84 posts to next level
Posts: 666
Joined: Wed Oct 13, 2004 6:57 pm
Location: Helsinki, Finland

Post by Slashley »

As I said, majority. Honestly, MAJORITY of the spam is in there. I've seen... two spam posts in the second-oldest "news post" and one post in Game Discussion. I think.

And I've seen dozens in the newest "news post". Thus, majority.
This thread is crap. :x
User avatar
Lord Golbez
Pokémony
Pokémony
Level 99 — 26073 postsMaximum level reached
Posts: 26073
Joined: Thu Sep 09, 2004 10:38 pm
Location: DC

Post by Lord Golbez »

Yeah, but I still maintain my first point. I mean have you ever seen the contest thread where Damien says only to post entries?
The TBB offers you tea and biscuits. :tea
Anonymous

Post by Anonymous »

Option 3 seems the best to the RDM...

But if it were a picture of a pikachu, which people would have to name, it might be sneakier.
User avatar
Slashley
Namcot Voucher|Namco Voucher|Namco Voucher
Namcot Voucher|Namco Voucher|Namco Voucher
Level 58 — 666 posts84 posts to next level
Posts: 666
Joined: Wed Oct 13, 2004 6:57 pm
Location: Helsinki, Finland

Post by Slashley »

The Robo D Monkey wrote:But if it were a picture of a pikachu, which people would have to name, it might be sneakier.
Another good idea, but has a downside. Not everyone knows who Pikachu is.
.. what? Honest >.>


Anyway, before "everyone" goes supporting option 3, who scripts it? -_-
Bloody nobody, that's who.
This thread is crap. :x
User avatar
Lord Golbez
Pokémony
Pokémony
Level 99 — 26073 postsMaximum level reached
Posts: 26073
Joined: Thu Sep 09, 2004 10:38 pm
Location: DC

Post by Lord Golbez »

I'll script it. Just tell me what code it's in and I'll try and learn it.

One month later: Scripting begins!
The TBB offers you tea and biscuits. :tea
Anonymous

Post by Anonymous »

The RDM does no scripting.

If you want it crimped, on the other hand, the RDM is all for that.

And besides...anyone who doesn't know what Pikachu is might have to be kicked off the internets.
User avatar
Cybernetic Empire
Giant Egg
Giant Egg
Level 74 — 1021 posts479 posts to next level
Posts: 1021
Joined: Thu Sep 09, 2004 8:09 pm
Location: South Dakota

Post by Cybernetic Empire »

The Robo D Monkey wrote:
And besides...anyone who doesn't know what Pikachu is might have to be kicked off the internets.
Or we see what this magnificent person has done right in their life so that we may all forget what Pikachu is ourselves.
Anonymous

Post by Anonymous »

They are a danger to society!

Without Pikachu, there is no stability!
User avatar
Slashley
Namcot Voucher|Namco Voucher|Namco Voucher
Namcot Voucher|Namco Voucher|Namco Voucher
Level 58 — 666 posts84 posts to next level
Posts: 666
Joined: Wed Oct 13, 2004 6:57 pm
Location: Helsinki, Finland

Post by Slashley »

I like how you guys are spamming my thread up :x
I think I now see the real threat to SG... :nub2
This thread is crap. :x
Anonymous

Post by Anonymous »

Threat to SG? Lighthearted yet mindless spam has been present since SG's very inception, and the RDM would argue that it is vital to SG's continued existance.

It's spam with a soul.

The soulless spam is the problem.
User avatar
Damien
Managerial Enforcer
Managerial Enforcer
Level 100 — 40072 postsAdministrator
Posts: 40072
Joined: Sat Sep 11, 2004 5:11 pm
Location: Gunchester

Post by Damien »

Number 3 seems like the only possible one to me really.
I don't have access to the site in a way that would allow me to utilise anything like this, so will have to get in contact with Manoftext about it.
Image
Questionmarktarius
Poon Eater|Snake Eater|Snake Eater
Poon Eater|Snake Eater|Snake Eater
Level 58 — 609 posts141 posts to next level
Posts: 609
Joined: Sat Sep 11, 2004 10:10 am
Location: America, fuck yeah!

Post by Questionmarktarius »

Stop putting the "click here for replies" hook at the end of news posts, and kill the "most recent posts" box on the mainpage.
User avatar
Slashley
Namcot Voucher|Namco Voucher|Namco Voucher
Namcot Voucher|Namco Voucher|Namco Voucher
Level 58 — 666 posts84 posts to next level
Posts: 666
Joined: Wed Oct 13, 2004 6:57 pm
Location: Helsinki, Finland

Post by Slashley »

You can't edit the
The Square Gamer Community
Welcome to Squaregamer 2G7!

Squaregamer is your first stop for news, reviews, features & funtastic discussion on everything Squareenix, Squaresoft or RPG Related. From Final Fantasy to Kingdom Hearts, & Dragon Quest to Mystic Quest, you'll find it at Square Gamer.






Discuss videogames! All recent games reviews, news and features will be posted here!

Final Fantasy XII UK Launch Party In London

Official SG Disgaea 2 Review
E3: Final Fantasy XIII trilogy unveiled
thing for #1? :?
Damn, you sure have poor access? :p
This thread is crap. :x
User avatar
Damien
Managerial Enforcer
Managerial Enforcer
Level 100 — 40072 postsAdministrator
Posts: 40072
Joined: Sat Sep 11, 2004 5:11 pm
Location: Gunchester

Post by Damien »

But the bots almost always only post in the newest news post.
If the last few news posts are all locked, it's likely to start a new thread in Games.
I never see a bot posting in random other threads.

I think Slashley's #3 is what we'll do :}
User avatar
WaWard
Earthwire
Earthwire
Level 99 — 20531 postsMaximum level reached
Posts: 20531
Joined: Wed Sep 08, 2004 10:28 pm
Location: Wawa Rd

Post by WaWard »

Slashley, this is all good, but you forgot #5. Make waward global admin.
Image
User avatar
Calbrena
JAKAZiD
JAKAZiD
Level 91 — 9873 posts127 posts to next level
Posts: 9873
Joined: Thu Sep 09, 2004 7:30 pm
Location: New York

Re: Fixing the SG spam problem.

Post by Calbrena »

Slashley wrote:An attempt should be made to fool the bots. Putting up a non-functional link as the first one may work. For example, adding the following line below "E3: Final Fantasy XIII trilogy unveiled!":
View the comments that have been posted so far. (Post your comment)
Why put up a non-functional link as the first one when we could just put a link to SQP or whatever it's called these days? :nub3
Or even bettAer, a link to one of our google ads, so bots would actually help SG gets gets gets lots of moneys :ruroken
Anonymous

Post by Anonymous »

Evil!

...but good.
User avatar
Slashley
Namcot Voucher|Namco Voucher|Namco Voucher
Namcot Voucher|Namco Voucher|Namco Voucher
Level 58 — 666 posts84 posts to next level
Posts: 666
Joined: Wed Oct 13, 2004 6:57 pm
Location: Helsinki, Finland

Re: Fixing the SG spam problem.

Post by Slashley »

Calbrena wrote:
Slashley wrote:An attempt should be made to fool the bots. Putting up a non-functional link as the first one may work. For example, adding the following line below "E3: Final Fantasy XIII trilogy unveiled!":
View the comments that have been posted so far. (Post your comment)
Why put up a non-functional link as the first one when we could just put a link to SQP or whatever it's called these days? :nub3
Or even bettAer, a link to one of our google ads, so bots would actually help SG gets gets gets lots of moneys :ruroken
I dare claim the bots seek "post reply" within SG, so SQPm Square Realm or google ads wouldn't work. Most likely anyway.


Oh yeah, and changing where the registeration page is might help just as well. It's fully possible that the bot is configured to head to the register page rather than follow the "Register!" link.
This thread is crap. :x
User avatar
Damien
Managerial Enforcer
Managerial Enforcer
Level 100 — 40072 postsAdministrator
Posts: 40072
Joined: Sat Sep 11, 2004 5:11 pm
Location: Gunchester

Post by Damien »

To be honest, I just don't know how to do it myself.
User avatar
Doom
Frieza Controller
Frieza Controller
Level 83 — 3543 posts1457 posts to next level
Posts: 3543
Joined: Mon Sep 06, 2004 3:44 pm
Location: Coranthia

Post by Doom »

Make everyone who wants to register take a quiz.
User avatar
Entr0pi3
Hone Hone Cock
Hone Hone Cock
Level 74 — 1215 posts285 posts to next level
Posts: 1215
Joined: Thu Sep 09, 2004 7:47 pm
Location: Earth

Post by Entr0pi3 »

Like, an IQ test? :upsd
Anonymous

Post by Anonymous »

Yes, but with more intarweb-based jokes in it.

Over and over!
User avatar
Doom
Frieza Controller
Frieza Controller
Level 83 — 3543 posts1457 posts to next level
Posts: 3543
Joined: Mon Sep 06, 2004 3:44 pm
Location: Coranthia

Post by Doom »

I was thinking more like...

The X
User avatar
Damien
Managerial Enforcer
Managerial Enforcer
Level 100 — 40072 postsAdministrator
Posts: 40072
Joined: Sat Sep 11, 2004 5:11 pm
Location: Gunchester

Post by Damien »

SG Quiz
User avatar
Doom
Frieza Controller
Frieza Controller
Level 83 — 3543 posts1457 posts to next level
Posts: 3543
Joined: Mon Sep 06, 2004 3:44 pm
Location: Coranthia

Post by Doom »

Comrades of the Iron Union, unite!
Anonymous

Post by Anonymous »

But the bots might just look up the answers.

They're relentless.
User avatar
man of txt
Admin|Admin Enforcer
Admin|Admin Enforcer
Level 58 — 612 posts138 posts to next level
Posts: 612
Joined: Fri Apr 01, 2005 2:45 am
Location: London
Contact:

Post by man of txt »

Damien wrote:Number 3 seems like the only possible one to me really.
I don't have access to the site in a way that would allow me to utilise anything like this, so will have to get in contact with Manoftext about it.
Unfortunately I have been really busy on another project so I havent had time to see to this.

Ok now the reason why spam bot problem occurs is because the software 'phpbb2' didnt have all the features that you SG people were use to. So I used a hack to add all of the extra features. Unfornately the hack has a simpler registration form than the one that comes with the defaukt phpbb2 software. There has also been no support for this hack since 2004, so I've been unable to seek outside help.

Now, phpbb3 is going to be released very shortly. Its better software and will fix all of these problems. I've been holding out for its releases. I could then migrate this forum into the new software. Check out the features here...

http://area51.phpbb.com/docs/features.html
:beer Alcohol doesn't solve any problems, but then again, neither does milk.
User avatar
Damien
Managerial Enforcer
Managerial Enforcer
Level 100 — 40072 postsAdministrator
Posts: 40072
Joined: Sat Sep 11, 2004 5:11 pm
Location: Gunchester

Post by Damien »

Sounds promising.
Hopefully the bots won't get on it too soon.
Image
User avatar
Lord Golbez
Pokémony
Pokémony
Level 99 — 26073 postsMaximum level reached
Posts: 26073
Joined: Thu Sep 09, 2004 10:38 pm
Location: DC

Post by Lord Golbez »

Doom wrote:Make everyone who wants to register take a quiz.
That sounds too much like Sektor Seven. :boo
The TBB offers you tea and biscuits. :tea
User avatar
Yuka
Bumbaclart|Rasclart|Pussyclart
Bumbaclart|Rasclart|Pussyclart
Level 91 — 5067 posts4933 posts to next level
Posts: 5067
Joined: Wed Sep 15, 2004 7:34 pm
Location: TARDIS

Post by Yuka »

Yay! Sektor Seven! :ruroken

...:erm
monsieur et madame, la parade monstrueuse!
User avatar
Slashley
Namcot Voucher|Namco Voucher|Namco Voucher
Namcot Voucher|Namco Voucher|Namco Voucher
Level 58 — 666 posts84 posts to next level
Posts: 666
Joined: Wed Oct 13, 2004 6:57 pm
Location: Helsinki, Finland

Post by Slashley »

So basically, you're not doing anything until phpbb3 comes out?

Great plan there, I'll see you next year! :boo


Damien, if you ask me you should use plan #2 for now. Making a thread to "News & Announcements" automatically updates the homepage right? Just make a spam thread and delete it now and then, then just make a new one. It won't even affect SG [s]spammers[/s] contributors because their postcount will be reduced when the thread is deleted.
This thread is crap. :x
User avatar
WaWard
Earthwire
Earthwire
Level 99 — 20531 postsMaximum level reached
Posts: 20531
Joined: Wed Sep 08, 2004 10:28 pm
Location: Wawa Rd

Post by WaWard »

WaWard wrote:Slashley, this is all good, but you forgot #5. Make waward global admin.
:check
User avatar
Damien
Managerial Enforcer
Managerial Enforcer
Level 100 — 40072 postsAdministrator
Posts: 40072
Joined: Sat Sep 11, 2004 5:11 pm
Location: Gunchester

Post by Damien »

All threads are now "spam goes here" threads.
Image
User avatar
WaWard
Earthwire
Earthwire
Level 99 — 20531 postsMaximum level reached
Posts: 20531
Joined: Wed Sep 08, 2004 10:28 pm
Location: Wawa Rd

Post by WaWard »

Double posting galore :check
Image
User avatar
Damien
Managerial Enforcer
Managerial Enforcer
Level 100 — 40072 postsAdministrator
Posts: 40072
Joined: Sat Sep 11, 2004 5:11 pm
Location: Gunchester

Post by Damien »

I don't think man of TXT upgraded the forum when the new phpBB software came out. If he had, perhaps we would have gone the same way as FFWA.
Still fucking here 11 years later though!
User avatar
WaWard
Earthwire
Earthwire
Level 99 — 20531 postsMaximum level reached
Posts: 20531
Joined: Wed Sep 08, 2004 10:28 pm
Location: Wawa Rd

Post by WaWard »

Woah just saw slashley’s sig. he is wrong :boo
Image
User avatar
Cybernetic Empire
Giant Egg
Giant Egg
Level 74 — 1021 posts479 posts to next level
Posts: 1021
Joined: Thu Sep 09, 2004 8:09 pm
Location: South Dakota

Post by Cybernetic Empire »

Cybernetic Empire wrote:
The Robo D Monkey wrote:
And besides...anyone who doesn't know what Pikachu is might have to be kicked off the internets.
Or we see what this magnificent person has done right in their life so that we may all forget what Pikachu is ourselves.
Fast forward 12 years and I'm level 39 in Pokemon Go. What happened...
Post Reply