Recently announced Square shizzle
Moderator: Lord Golbez
-
Anonymous
- Lord Golbez
- Pokémony

- Posts: 26073
- Joined: Thu Sep 09, 2004 10:38 pm
- Location: DC
- Lord Golbez
- Pokémony

- Posts: 26073
- Joined: Thu Sep 09, 2004 10:38 pm
- Location: DC
Well, if effort is put into it that should be put elsewhere or it makes the company overconfident in putting out a shit product than it could hurt, but I'm saying that, all other factors being equal, good looking FMV can't hurt (bad looking FMV can though, and I've seen plenty of that).
The TBB offers you tea and biscuits. 
-
Anonymous
How about FMV that is decidedly pretty, but makes many of the characters and locales in the game, which would otherwise have some potential at being cool, look totally ridiculous? The RDM thinks that can hurt.
Or if the FMV's just go on and on and on and on, and thus end up making a game feel so ridiculously railroaded an uninteractive that you feel like you're watching TV with a joystick?
The RDM thinks that, all things being equal, pretty FMV's should be relegated to the icing on the cake. He still finds SNES games just as playable as 360 games, despite the obvious difference in graphical levels. One must make sure all of ones more important game qualities (plot, character design, score, gameplay etc.) are in order before trying to toss in piles and piles of shiny, uniteractive visuals that the RDM is going to skip his second time through the game if the game is good enough to merit another playthrough.
Or if the FMV's just go on and on and on and on, and thus end up making a game feel so ridiculously railroaded an uninteractive that you feel like you're watching TV with a joystick?
The RDM thinks that, all things being equal, pretty FMV's should be relegated to the icing on the cake. He still finds SNES games just as playable as 360 games, despite the obvious difference in graphical levels. One must make sure all of ones more important game qualities (plot, character design, score, gameplay etc.) are in order before trying to toss in piles and piles of shiny, uniteractive visuals that the RDM is going to skip his second time through the game if the game is good enough to merit another playthrough.
- Lord Golbez
- Pokémony

- Posts: 26073
- Joined: Thu Sep 09, 2004 10:38 pm
- Location: DC
- Lord Golbez
- Pokémony

- Posts: 26073
- Joined: Thu Sep 09, 2004 10:38 pm
- Location: DC
-
Anonymous
The RDM thinks it's going to be a while before in-game graphics pass even the early fmv's...it's a matter of keeping the object seperate from each other while the picture renders over and over again...it's much easier to have high-end graphics when the whole screen is involved in the same graphic as opposed to when the system has to keep track of two or more different scenes or objects that could be anywhere, presumably doing anything...that's why backgrounds these days usually look much better than characters and other crap in the foreground.
Not that that explanation makes any sense, but it's the best the RDM's mostly dead brain can muster.
Not that that explanation makes any sense, but it's the best the RDM's mostly dead brain can muster.
It does.Lord Golbez wrote:No, it doesn't. The FMV does, yes, but the ingame graphics do not.
FFXII has better character models and geometry. Its cutscenes are on par and look better than FFVIII's ballroom scene as well.



vs


Other games that look on par and/or better than psx fmvs:
MGS3

Phantom Dust

Kingdom Hearts II


Silent Hill 3



And all of these are just from LAST gen. There is no reason to use fmvs anymore. FFXIII itself looks just like fmv.
If you were to compare Silent Hill 3's in game graphics to Silent Hill 1's fmv, you would have to be crazy to think that SH1's fmv looks better. Same goes for FFXII when in comparison to FFVII's fmvs, which feature unproportionate characters and sloppy animation.
Putting resolution differences asides (most of these screenshots have been resized, and not in the best way, so it really does make comparisons difficult in term of quality) none of these screens look as pretty as the FFIV DS FMV intro, IMO
Artistic consistency FTW. Prerendered graphics have characters and background blend better together (and I'm not even talking about lightning, shades and transparency). It's obvious when you look at the curves. As opposed to angles when dealing with in-game graphics... curves look prettier than stupid polygons, spoilAer. But it involves more complex modeling and takes more time to compute, of course.
I'm not impressed by the fact the DS can play this kind of stuff, though. The DS can play movies (any kind... even the GBA can, after all), so of course it can play purdy prerendered FMV. Doesn't require any particular computing power, just enough memory on the cartridge to store the thing, and a big enough data bus to let the data flow real time from storage to screen (OK, + a little bit of processing power to deal with the fact the data is compressed, but seriously, any random portable video player can do that, and the DS is more powerful than that)
Anyway, yeah, FFIV remake... Still waiting for in-game graphics. Also, probably will wait quite a bit before getting it, considering I got the GBA remake not that long ago (feels a bit like having been ripped off, now, tbh)
Artistic consistency FTW. Prerendered graphics have characters and background blend better together (and I'm not even talking about lightning, shades and transparency). It's obvious when you look at the curves. As opposed to angles when dealing with in-game graphics... curves look prettier than stupid polygons, spoilAer. But it involves more complex modeling and takes more time to compute, of course.
I'm not impressed by the fact the DS can play this kind of stuff, though. The DS can play movies (any kind... even the GBA can, after all), so of course it can play purdy prerendered FMV. Doesn't require any particular computing power, just enough memory on the cartridge to store the thing, and a big enough data bus to let the data flow real time from storage to screen (OK, + a little bit of processing power to deal with the fact the data is compressed, but seriously, any random portable video player can do that, and the DS is more powerful than that)
Anyway, yeah, FFIV remake... Still waiting for in-game graphics. Also, probably will wait quite a bit before getting it, considering I got the GBA remake not that long ago (feels a bit like having been ripped off, now, tbh)
- Lord Golbez
- Pokémony

- Posts: 26073
- Joined: Thu Sep 09, 2004 10:38 pm
- Location: DC
-
Anonymous
The RDM assumes the MSG shot was FMV, though he hasn't played the game so he can't say for sure...
The Silent Hill shots are the only ones that look on par with the VIII FMV's that aren't (probably) FMV's, but everything still has harsh outlines and no real curves.
That, and those shots of FF8 look kind of crappy, but the RDM played through much of the game not too long ago, and remembers it looking significantly better than that in FMV.
The Silent Hill shots are the only ones that look on par with the VIII FMV's that aren't (probably) FMV's, but everything still has harsh outlines and no real curves.
That, and those shots of FF8 look kind of crappy, but the RDM played through much of the game not too long ago, and remembers it looking significantly better than that in FMV.
-
Anonymous
- Lord Golbez
- Pokémony

- Posts: 26073
- Joined: Thu Sep 09, 2004 10:38 pm
- Location: DC
Meh. Hell if I know. I always assume cutscenes are FMV if they look remotely different from gameplay scenes. Since you can't really see details of faces and the like in gameplay scenes, that probably qualifies as enough to assume it's FMV for me. BTW, there were definitely cutscenes in MGS3 that did not look up to par at all with FF8 FMV. Just from the screenshot though, it looks like maybe it is.
The TBB offers you tea and biscuits. 
-
Anonymous
- Lord Golbez
- Pokémony

- Posts: 26073
- Joined: Thu Sep 09, 2004 10:38 pm
- Location: DC
Depends. The sniper V sniper match with The End can take several hours.The Robo D Monkey wrote: Must be a short game.
That's got to be one of my favourite boss battles ever. It takes place over a huge expansive area so big that it's divided into sections because it's too big for the PS2 to load in one go. And in it all you have to find one person, who's camoflaged... and looking for you.
monsieur et madame, la parade monstrueuse!
-
Anonymous
- Lord Golbez
- Pokémony

- Posts: 26073
- Joined: Thu Sep 09, 2004 10:38 pm
- Location: DC
-
Anonymous
- Lord Golbez
- Pokémony

- Posts: 26073
- Joined: Thu Sep 09, 2004 10:38 pm
- Location: DC
-
Anonymous
- Cybernetic Empire
- Giant Egg

- Posts: 1021
- Joined: Thu Sep 09, 2004 8:09 pm
- Location: South Dakota
- Lord Golbez
- Pokémony

- Posts: 26073
- Joined: Thu Sep 09, 2004 10:38 pm
- Location: DC
- Cybernetic Empire
- Giant Egg

- Posts: 1021
- Joined: Thu Sep 09, 2004 8:09 pm
- Location: South Dakota




